Game 139: Brewers 9 Pirates 3

I don't really know what else to say here other than this really, obviously was not the Pirates' night. It was apparent from the second inning onwards that Francisco Liriano had absolutely nothing tonight, but he was allowed to stay out on the mound until the Brewers had seven runs. This is a larger and more philosophical debate for another day (and I want to be clear that I'm not really blaming Hurdle for leaving Liriano out on the mound too long, necessarily, because pretty much every manager in baseball will stick with his ace through the third inning unless things get apocalyptically ugly), but nights like tonight are really hard to watch when it becomes apparent that a pitcher doesn't have it, but he has to stay out on the mound until he gives up the requisite number of runs to be removed. Liriano came out dealing in the first, but he was almost equally as flat in the second and he was lucky to escape with only the two runs scored. In the third, it seemed obvious after Aramis Ramirez's double that leaving him on the mound was tantamount to throwing in the towel, but he faced five more batters and allowed two more runs. There's no easy answer here, of course, because some nights guys look absolutely brutal early on and settle in and are fine, but the third inning tonight was just awful to watch almost from the outset and it's frustrating that those sorts of innings seem impossible to avoid once they begin.

In any case, even though the Pirates were down 7-2 at that point, they had plenty of opportunities to get back into the game.In the fifth, Andrew McCutchen homered and Wily Peralta followed that up with something that looked an awful lot like throwing at Justin Morneau's head, which put Morneau on first with no outs. Somehow, though, Morneau was thrown out at the plate on Marlon Byrd's double into the left-center gap that both split the outfielders and took it's sweet old time bouncing to the fence. If Morneau scores, the Pirates are down 7-4 with a runner on third and nobody out. Instead, Morneau was thrown out and Byrd was stranded at third. In the seventh, Neil Walker lead off with a double, McCutchen walked, and Pedro Alvarez was hit by a pitch with two outs to load the bases. The Pirates failed to score.

A good rule of thumb is that if your starter gives up seven runs and you leave 12 runners on base with only two hits in scoring position, chances are awfully low that you did not win. These sorts of games happen from time to time in baseball, of course, but they get a little tougher to stomach when they happen in September. The Cardinals just finished up a 16-inning win against the Reds, which means that they've cut the Pirates lead to one game and they can cut it to a 1/2 game tomorrow. If that happens, this weekend is going to be stressful.

Pat Lackey

About Pat Lackey

In 2005, I started a WHYGAVS instead of working on organic chemistry homework. Many years later, I've written about baseball and the Pirates for a number of sites all across the internet, but WHYGAVS is still my home. I still haven't finished that O-Chem homework, though.